How can you specify weights for a statistical analysis? Hmmm, that's a "weighty" question! Many people on discussion forums ask "What is a weight variable?" and "How do you choose a weight for each observation?" This article gives a brief overview of weight variables in statistics and includes examples of how weights are used in SAS.
Different kinds of weight variables
One source of confusion is that different areas of statistics use weights in different ways. All weights are not created equal! The weights in survey statistics have a different interpretation from the weights in a weighted least squares regression.
Let's start with a basic definition. A weight variable provides a value (the weight) for each observation in a data set. The i_th weight value, wi, is the weight for the i_th observation. For most applications, a valid weight is nonnegative. A zero weight usually means that you want to exclude the observation from the analysis. Observations that have relatively large weights have more influence in the analysis than observations that have smaller weights. An unweighted analysis is the same as a weighted analysis in which all weights are 1.
There are several kinds of weight variables in statistics. At the 2007 Joint Statistical Meetings in Denver, I discussed weighted statistical graphics for two kinds of statistical weights: survey weights and regression weights. An audience member informed me that STATA software provides four definitions of weight variables, as follows:
- Frequency weights: A frequency variable specifies that each observation is repeated multiple times. Each frequency value is a nonnegative integer.
- Survey weights: Survey weights (also called sampling weights or probability weights) indicate that an observation in a survey represents a certain number of people in a finite population. Survey weights are often the reciprocals of the selection probabilities for the survey design.
- Analytical weights: An analytical weight (sometimes called an inverse variance weight or a regression weight) specifies that the i_th observation comes from a sub-population with variance σ2/wi, where σ2 is a common variance and wi is the weight of the i_th observation. These weights are used in multivariate statistics and in a meta-analyses where each "observation" is actually the mean of a sample.
- Importance weights: According to a STATA developer, an "importance weight" is a STATA-specific term that is intended "for programmers, not data analysts." The developer says that the formulas "may have no statistical validity" but can be useful as a programming convenience. Although I have never used STATA, I imagine that a primary use is to downweight the influence of outliers. The REWEIGHT statement in PROC REG served a similar purpose in the years before robust regression methods were implemented in SAS.
Frequencies are not weights
I have previously argued that a frequency variable is not a weight variable. I provided an example that shows the distinction between a frequency variable and a weight variable in regression. Briefly, a frequency variable is a notational convenience that enables you to compactly represent the data. A frequency variable determines the sample size (and the degrees of freedom), but using a frequency variable is always equivalent to "expanding" the data set. (To expand the data, create fi identical observations when the i_th value of the frequency variable is fi.) An analysis of the expanded data is identical to the same analysis on the original data that uses a frequency variable.
In SAS, the FREQ statement enables you to specify a frequency variable in most procedures. Ironically, in PROC FREQ you use the WEIGHT statement to specify frequencies. Because weights can be non-integer,the WEIGHT statement enables you to analyze tables that contain expected counts, percentages, and other non-integer values.
Have survey data? Use survey weights
If you have survey data, you should analyze it by using survey weights. The sum of the survey weights equals the population size. Using survey weights enables you to make correct inferences about the finite population that is represented by the survey.
In SAS, you can use the SAS SURVEY procedures to analyze survey data. The SURVEY procedures (including SURVEYMEANS, SURVEYFREQ, and SURVEYREG) also support stratified samples and strata weights.
Inverse variance weights
Inverse variance weights are appropriate for regression and other multivariate analyses. When you include a weight variable in a multivariate analysis, the crossproduct matrix is computed as X`WX, where W is the diagonal matrix of weights and X is the data matrix (possibly centered or standardized). In these analyses, the weight of an observation is assumed to be inversely proportional to the variance of the subpopulation from which that observation was sampled. You can "manually" reproduce a lot of formulas for weighted multivariate statistics by multiplying each row of the data matrix (and the response vector) by the square root of the appropriate weight.
In particular, if you use a weight variable in a regression procedure, you get a weighted regression analysis. For regression, the right side of the normal equations is X`WY.
You can also use weights to analyze a set of means, such as you might encounter in meta-analysis or an analysis of means. The weight that you specify for the i_th mean should be inversely proportional to the variance of the i_th sample. Equivalently, the weight for the i_th group is (approximately) proportional to the sample size of the i_th group.
In SAS, most regression procedures support WEIGHT statements. For example, PROC REG performs a weighted least squares regression. The multivariate analysis procedures (DISRIM, FACTOR, PRINCOMP, ...) use weights to form a weighted covariance or correlation matrix. You can use PROC GLM to compute a meta-analyze of data that are the means from previous studies.
What happens if you "make up" a weight variable?
Analysts can (and do!) create weights arbitrarily based on "gut feelings." You might say, "I don't trust the value of this observation, so I'm going to downweight it." Suppose you assign Observation 1 twice as much weight as Observation 2 because you feel that Observation 1 is twice as "trustworthy." How does a multivariate procedure interpret those weights?
In statistics, precision is the inverse of the variance. When you use those weights you are implicitly stating that you believe that Observation 2 is from a population whose variance is twice as large as the population variance for Observation 1. In other words, "less trust" means that you have less faith in the precision of the measurement for Observation 2 and more faith in the precision of Observation 1.
Examples of weighted analyses in SAS
In SAS, many procedures support a WEIGHT statement. The documentation for the procedure describes how the procedure incorporates weights. In addition to the previously mentioned procedures, many Base SAS procedures compute weighted descriptive statistics. For some examples of weighted statistical analyses in SAS and how to interpret the results, see the following articles:
- How to compute and interpret a weighted mean
- How to compute and interpret weighted quantiles or weighted percentiles
- How to compute and visualize a weighted linear regression
- Create and interpret a weighted histogram
WANT MORE GREAT INSIGHTS MONTHLY? | SUBSCRIBE TO THE SAS TECH REPORT