Tuesday, April 14. 2009Can Performance Management Combine the Best of Soviet Planning and Capitalism?Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
"Russians have strengths.. the causes of the economic meltdown produced by capitalism" - In such cases, I can't understand why companies like GM of which surely uses "central planning" failed, likely to bailout declaring "bankruptcy"? I agree that PM empowers central planning by linking true customer preferences and needs to the “central plan", but in this case what went wrong? Weren't true customer preferences considered while developing the central plan? Instead of "Let's go" GM's Fritz should "Let go!".
Intelligent comparison about Russian musicians and writers! and about the Russian-American writers like Nabokov . A mix flavor? Like Nabokov wrote “The breaking of a wave cannot explain the whole sea.” Is PM the wave and the Organization the see? (only a friendly provocation!)
To Kitipan --- There will be endless debates about "what went wrong" with General Motors. From a Performance Management perspective I wonder if it was poorly formulated strategy (which is the responsibility of the GM's executive leadership) or if a valid strategy was not adequately or quickly executed (which is arguably where Performance Management methodologies fit in.
to Luis Moniz --- As you know I like analogies and metaphors to understand things. My interpretation is the waves are the external forces and pressures upon an organization, where the organization is the sea. When it is calm, life can be good, but a ship should still try to get to its destination (its strategy) on schedule. When the weather is turbulent, Performance Management methodologies navigate the course, and ideally should apply "predictive analytics" to forecast where and when the storms will come.
"and their maligned Soviet central planning is now not looking so bad as we better understand the causes of the economic meltdown produced by capitalism"
In fact, it was centrally planned interest rates by the federal reserve that contributed largely to the instability and economic meltdown. The current situation actually provides one more example of the pitfalls of planning. With regard to the auto industry, the manipulation of energy markets through environmental regulation, and CAFE standards are further examples of the pitfalls of attempts at central planning. It is not that the bankers and automakers were shortsighted in their plans, but the uncertainty created by these government interventions trumped their business models. More planning likely isn't the answer since that is what 'got us into this mess.' I think SAS would be a great tool for generating a strategy in an environment of uncertainty created by ever more government intervention, but this will always be a challenge in such a 'mixed' economy. "In the days of the USSR this link was weak or missing" The missing link was Prices. Prices are the true link between customer needs and preferences and outcomes, not plans. Prices represent trade-offs based on the knowledge and preferences of millions of individuals and provide incentives to act on that information to allocate resources efficiently. In absence of prices, planners must rely on the limited knowledge and preferences of a few managers or bureaucrats with poor incentives to act in the best interest of society. Soviet style planning in general could never replace the superiority of market -based outcomes for an economy as a whole- no matter how powerful the analytic software. Within organizations where resources must be allocated by methods of non-price rationing- SAS would be a great tool for making the best use of limited information. I think that must be the message and the main point of this post. ( See Hayek 'The Use of Knowledge in Society' American Economic Review 1945) |
ABOUT GARY
Gary Cokins, CPIM is Global Product Marketing Manager for Performance Management at SAS, the world’s leader in business intelligence, and analytical software. He is an internationally recognized expert, speaker, and author. Read more.
BOOKS, ARTICLES & MORE
This look at current performance management trends isn’t a dry recipe or "how-to." It examines multiple methodologies and behavioral change management to overcome the natural resistance to change.
Read more.
The blog content appearing on this site does not necessarily represent the opinions of SAS. Your use of this blog is governed by the Terms of Use.
QuicksearchArchivesShow tagged entriesaberdeen accountability activity-based activity-based costing adoption rate africa alignment analyst analytics analytics-based performance management analytics statistics art Ashit athena b-eye-network balanced scorecard banking behavior change book authors Buckminster Fuller business analytics business intelligence buytendijk chief performance officer cnn correlation cosmonaut cpo CRM culture customer focus customer value darwin decision making downturn dreamer education employee empowerment enterprise performance optimization enterprise risk management ethics examples executive framework fraud full vision futuristic performance management government howard dresner hungary institutionalization italy kpis leadership learning legacy management march madness market focus model multi-tasking newton obama optimism optimization orchestra organizational transformation paladino. government Panjwani performance performance management performance measurement poorly performing organizations predictions predictive analytics predictive performance management privacy private equity firms profitability racehorse realist recorded interview rick sherman risk Russia Schiff SEB shareholder value management sports strategy execution strategy maps Sweden talent Taylor teamwork text analytics texting text mining turkey twitter
Top Exitsen.wikipedia.org (72)
www.dmreview.com (60) www.sas.com (52) www.dashboardinsight.com (27) www.balancedscorecard.org (26) www.imanet.org (24) www.wiley.com (16) books.google.com (13) www.bpmmag.net (13) www.bscol.com (13) |